1. This forum is dedicated for discussion of Theories & Speculations created using our Theories & Speculations platform.
    • To publish a new theory or speculation, click here
    • To see a list of all theories & speculations, read, rate and review click here

Shanks and Eustass Kid are Intended Counterparts

Discussion in 'The Theory Archive' started by Fiasco, Jul 26, 2016.

Tags:

Share This Page

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Fiasco

    Fiasco

    Messages:
    49
    Likes Received:
    104
    Trophy Points:
    1,440
    Bounty Points:
    0
    Let's talk about Shanks, Kid and how I think Oda intended for them to be similar, yet polar opposites ideologically.
    (This is not a theory about how they're related by blood. This is a theory discussing their character design, ideologies and how it plays into the themes of One Piece).

    -Starting with their appearance:
    Things that are Similar:
    They both have red hair (duh), they both are missing their left arms, and have scars over their left eyes.
    Things that are Different: Kid dresses much flashier, as opposed to Shanks who dresses very simplistic (this becomes important when we get to the ideology).
    [​IMG] [​IMG]

    -Personalities:
    Kid:
    Arrogant, violent, savage, merciless, prideful and egotistical.
    Shanks: Modest, tame, puts himself in danger for causes larger than himself, and doesn't care for petty conflict.

    -How this all Ties Together (The Ideology Part):
    Kid and Shanks represent how two people who fall into similar positions can react to them in different ways. When Shanks is bullied by some bandits at a bar, he laughs it off. When Kid is mocked for wanting to find the One Piece, he kills them. Or when they both lose their arms, Kid replaces his with a mechanical arm, but Shanks leaves his as it is. This has to do with how Shanks is simplistic and naturalistic. Shanks is all about the human spirit and will power. He doesn't use technology or devil fruits to gain an advantage, he uses his natural abilities as a human (Haki). Where as Kid uses technology and a devil fruit. I feel Shanks would view these things as unnecessary or as excessive; he goes as he is. This bit of philosophy becomes clearer by their clothing. Shanks's simplistic vibe is expressed through his casual/rugged attire; with his baggy pants, untucked buttondown, and sandels. Kid's flashy pants, vest and coat are polarizing to Shanks's wardrobe.

    The way they treat their enemies is another way their character philosophies differ. Shanks and his crew could have taken out those bandits in the bar, right then and there. But he chose to show some mercy and not induce violence over something as petty as spilled drinks and a little name calling. But when Kid travels to the New World and defeats Haritsu Kendiyo and his crew, (which, presumably for Shanks would have been enough), but Kid shows no mercy and kills them.

    Shanks and Kid also seem to face some similar hardships and situations, but the way they react/handle/cope is opposite to each other. Now there are a lot of characters in One Piece that are opposites of each other. But the reason I think Oda intended for a special and specific connection between them is their physical appearances and interactions with Luffy. We already went over their looks, but just to recap, they obviously bear similar wounds to each other. Now, Luffy takes after Shanks (the way he handles people, his philosophies, his values, ext.) and Kid is supposed to be Luffy's opposite/rival. We know this because Kid was the only supernova to have a higher bounty than Luffy, he was the only supernova whose vice captain/first mate also held a bounty high enough to be classified as a supernova, and Kid's giant metal arm was a parallel to Luffy's gear 3 pistol. So Kid is an opposite/rival to Luffy. The reason this supports the relation between Kid and Shanks is because, for the sake of the story, it's important that Luffy would meet someone who bares similar pain/experiences as Shanks, but handled it in the opposite manner; representing what Luffy could have become if he didn't follow Shanks's way of life (Kinda like Naruto and Gaara).

    Conclusion:
    Oda intentionally wrote for Kid and Shanks to have some similar bad experiences to represent a theme about how having the right attitude can make all the difference in life. He purposefully modeled kid to be noticeably (but not too obviously) similar to Shanks in appearance to create that parallel between the two characters.

    If you read everything, thank you. I know a lot of people have already touched on this topic, but I was just thinking about this and figured I would share my thoughts. I would also like to hear the community's thoughts if you people have any. Thank you.
     
  2. Icecream001

    Icecream001

    Messages:
    1,773
    Likes Received:
    9,114
    Trophy Points:
    13,990
    Bounty Points:
    5,200
    Wow it makes sense. A lot. Nice theory i agree with it!
     
    Onepiecefan9867, Vince and Fiasco like this.
  3. Fiasco

    Fiasco

    Messages:
    49
    Likes Received:
    104
    Trophy Points:
    1,440
    Bounty Points:
    0
    Thank you!:D
     
  4. Spider

    Spider

    Messages:
    1,783
    Likes Received:
    18,601
    Trophy Points:
    14,960
    Bounty Points:
    46,999
    Was a cool read bud, good effort
     
    Fiasco likes this.
  5. Kara22

    Kara22

    Messages:
    820
    Likes Received:
    4,137
    Trophy Points:
    12,110
    Bounty Points:
    200
    Yeah, I agree totally :yaaa: Kid is somewhat portrayed as Shanks's doppelganger (an evil shadow/double of every living person), He is everything that Shanks isn't, yet they look very alike. It will be interesting to watch, how Luffy will handle Kid, because they will fight sooner or later for sure (propably after he finds out about Kid's plans).
     
    Fiasco likes this.
  6. Fiasco

    Fiasco

    Messages:
    49
    Likes Received:
    104
    Trophy Points:
    1,440
    Bounty Points:
    0
    Doppelganger is a much better word, wish I thought of that. I also forgot about Kid's plan to take out Shanks, lol, that also adds to the theory:lmao:
     
    Kara22 likes this.
  7. Den_Den_Mushi

    Den_Den_Mushi

    Messages:
    2,843
    Likes Received:
    100,585
    Trophy Points:
    17,250
    Bounty Points:
    14,000
    Great theory! Just some other parallels I wanted to point out: Kid and Shanks both reject conventional morality, for example when Kid compares the morality of the Celestial Dragons and pirates at the auction house, and when Shanks in chapter 1 doesn't react when Lucky Roo shoots a bandit in the head. However, there are some clear differences as well...

    Shanks
    • Is respected by Sengoku, Mihawk and Kaido (I assume this is how he stopped Kaido going to Marineford), so much so that he was able to stop the war and retrieve Ace and WB's bodies.
    • Clashed evenly with old WB, using only one hand.

    Kid
    • Believed he and his alliance could take on Kaido, but just straight up got wrecked. His defeat was meant to show just how far the Supernovas are from being able to take on the Yonkou.
     
  8. santoryu kageoni

    santoryu kageoni

    Messages:
    207
    Likes Received:
    5,013
    Trophy Points:
    5,970
    Bounty Points:
    4,000
    Nice though I really dont think that he can even dream of going up against shanks...
     
  9. Divvens

    Divvens

    Messages:
    26,035
    Likes Received:
    262,662
    Trophy Points:
    32,950
    Bounty Points:
    849,984,950
    Hi @Fiasco!

    Earlier today our new platform for publishing theories & speculation went live, you can read the announcement post here for more information. I'm leaving this message here as your theory was posted recently or has had discussion recently.

    All theories in this section which are in the "thread" format will be archived and authors will have 30 days within which they can port their content over to the new platform, we have written a guide to help you port over your theories.

    If you have any questions, feel free to reach out via the Theories Help Desk.

    Regards,
    Divvens
    Team Oro Jackson
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice