Latest Reviews

  1. Cythone578
    Cythone578
    5/5,
    Interesting, very Interesting. The attention to detail was amazing and the theory itself was direct and had a great logic flow. Great Job!
  2. D jango
    D jango
    4/5,
    Probably that legend is shiki the golden lion. Just read again chapter 0, maybe the beast pirate are the project of shiki since 20 years ago. Shiki also resembling japanese culture, his clothes and his castle.
  3. Rorouni Zoro
    Rorouni Zoro
    5/5,
    I had the same thought while re-reading Ch. 865 yesterday, since everyone but Judge seem to be prepared for death and show no fear. If Judge’s the only one to die and leadership of Germa 66 transfers, it’d be one of the best deaths of the series.
    1. Cythone578
      Author's Response
      Exactly!

      Also, if it transferred by seniority and rank, it would transfer to Reiju since she's the oldest sibling. This would make the germa another powerful ally of the SH's.

      I also have a theory that at some point Sanji will develop his exoskeleton and his brothers are slowly developing emotion.
  4. D jango
    D jango
    4/5,
    Remember how strawhats fought ancient zombie of oars at thriller bark, that battle are really full of strategies. Every strawhats use his full potential. There is elements such as wind, water and ice to take down that ancient oars.
    My poin is no one will win in fighting kaido, they need to corporate to fight him.
    And, maybe Zoro will going to use wind elemental (zoro techniques) at the fight.
  5. Rej Discussions
    Rej Discussions
    5/5,
    Good idea nakama. Enjoyed that idea. Short and nice.
    You could improve the theory by adding pictures. The idea itself is worth 5 stars. Caught my attention.
    1. Cythone578
      Author's Response
      Thank you. I'll keep that into consideration w/ my next post.
  6. Law_Senpai
    Law_Senpai
    5/5,
    Honestly this is a good catch. If judge dies itll help with redeeming germa and it allows them all to potentially end up in wano too
    1. Cythone578
      Author's Response
      I doubt we'll be seeing the Vinsmokes so soon, or at the very least not in Wano. If we do, it'll probably be post-Jinbe and as a cover story until the final story arc.

      Many theorists were pointing to death foreshadows and thought Jinbe would die but I think he'll show up at a critical time in Wano to save the day (kinda similar to his reveal in Whole cake).

      However, this would also make fighting Big Mom pointless. Unless she herself challenges Luffy and threatens to attack Fishman island in retaliation.

      There are some holes in this as well but I'm confident that the Fishman AND Giants will be involved the next time that we see BM. Hey, she might even become an ally (somehow) by the end of this if it's revealed that Sanji was the one who made the cake.
  7. Theo Ries
    Theo Ries
    4/5,
    Very interesting... There's definitely a way out here, and it's got evidence from the manga as you pointed out. I'm glad you shared your idea with the community!

    On an aside, I'm certainly with the other comments. I would really encourage you to utilize pictures and subtitles. Many (speaking from personal experience) have been guilty of passing on reading text-only theories not knowing they were actually worthy reads.
    1. Cypher
      Author's Response
      Thank you.
      I appreciate your criticism. I might add some pictures in the next days when I have the time!
  8. Suuuuper
    Suuuuper
    5/5,
    Good read. I'll look crazy but it still believe the Cake is the catslyst To deal with Mama past and bring back her innocent but stupid nature and she Will be the only old generation big player who will still be an influence after Luffy becomes PK. It's not for nothing that Oda is trying to makes us like the BMP. The only one change that this crew need is from Mama.

    She got good goals : Wanting to everybody to leave in peace, not wanting anyone to leave her, enjoying life and having parties...

    But she just doesnt get that even if her goals are good her means to get them are evil. The cake will start the transformation and the BMP will be what WB was To Roger.
    1. Cypher
      Author's Response
      Thank you. Yeah, also Lola stating that her mother will help the straw hats when they need it. She was in contact with Loki, something tells me she knows the Carmel story and that's why she left Big Mom. To look for somebody who is strong and fearless enough to bring back the old Linlin.
  9. Afro Iceman
    Afro Iceman
    4/5,
    great theory bro.. But concept of War(Civil War) matches with Doflamingo too much.. Doffy is King and Celestial Dragon who came to power through treachery and Civil War and is main reason behind many Civil War in one piece world.. Everyone's expectation of all calamities being zoan can be oda's wish so he can threw surprise in..
    1. vikas
      Author's Response
      wano will definitely have civil war...well we can say most of the citizens are actually samurais and different clans. So if you think about the ultimate goal of unification and opening borders. There have to be a strife. With kozuki clan and allies at one side and shogun + allies at the other. The enemy clans are not enemies but citizens of wano so defeating them is not the solution. They have to make them switch sides or else ruling wont be easy for momo.
  10. Afro Iceman
    Afro Iceman
    4/5,
    good work but can't bet when Oda sensei on other end. nice nordic theory
  11. MasterD
    MasterD
    5/5,
    I find it very interesting and original also well researched and your arguments were explained well. Personally i think this theory should be featured
    1. Rob Gucci
      Author's Response
      Hey masterD! Thanks for telling me how much you liked it, it means a lot. And if this theory gets featured it’d be epic
  12. BossYimz
    BossYimz
    5/5,
    I definitely see Zoro having CoC in the future. I also think that he already unlocked. He just hasn't used it to knock out fodder like Luffy has.
    1. Shishio
      Author's Response
      Yeah he probably already has it..
  13. Captain Sexy Foxy
    Captain Sexy Foxy
    5/5,
    After reading ur theory, I actually can't stop imagining Zoro worrying about and being ashamed of his lowborn status and saying something like "Im not worthy of u guys",(and presence of Sanji will make it even worse and harder) and Luffy saying" I don't care who and where u are from, you are my nakama"!))
    1. Rob Gucci
      Author's Response
      That would make an amazing panel, good idea! Thanks for the review
  14. allsunday
    allsunday
    5/5,
    cake is dumb
    he should put a large of poison in it
    your theory hit the on the spot
    1. Nessos
      Author's Response
      Yeah in the end Bege was wrong again.

      It just ended her tantrum :)
  15. allsunday
    allsunday
    5/5,
    nice theory, if its true
    that's will explain why he didn't catagorize as human like law mention it after punk hazard arc
  16. Sect D
    Sect D
    5/5,
    Oda had indicated number of times of zoro already having CoC and you presented it well...
    1. Shishio
      Author's Response
      Thanks bruh.
  17. Cinera
    Cinera
    5/5,
    I agree, the Rayleigh parallel is the most convincing point for me.
    1. Shishio
      Author's Response
      Yeah plus if someone like Katakuri can have Haki, if wouldn't make much sense for Zoro to not have it.
  18. Theo Ries
    Theo Ries
    5/5,
    I love crew theories (even if I don't want a particular character) because many theorists seem to have a unique take on the possibilities. I also love patterns (mostly because Oda seems to definitely hold to them in a fashion. Put the two together with good writing and I'm bound to love the idea.
  19. Rorouni Zoro
    Rorouni Zoro
    4/5,
    While I’d be extremely surprised for BM and Vinsmokes to get along after this, but the fact that Pudding has physical evidence (memo-reel) of their kiss makes this plausible. Showing BM the reel and saying that they sealed the marriage could work, but Pudding would still need to stick around Incase of more cake cravings.
  20. Jeffrey zorofan
    Jeffrey zorofan
    4/5,
    personally i think that she will be very careful at lettingg strangers know she can read poneglyph, i meant her family was literally eliminated coz of it!! but otherwise i agree with the rest...

    also big news morgans may release the failed marriage of the 3eyed daughter of big mom... what if it's a common knowledge that 3 eyed tribe can hear the voice of all things? i wouldnt be surprised if the WG eliminated her people too!! What if BB sends a commander and his fleet to kidnap pudding instead, since big mom is weakened too??