Latest Reviews

  1. RUIYO
    RUIYO
    3/5,
    The connections you make are... good I guess... the lion thing I don't know doubt there is no question Kaido is the top dog in Wano. IT would be kind of anticlimactic to change that at this point. There is no point in hiding his identity with another name, the marines are wary of invading Wano already.

    The strongest point you have is the time line in which 22 years ago shiki broke out of impledown and 20 years ago Kaido plotted with Orochi to take down the Kozuki. The experiments and all that give a vibe of Shiki's doing, with Oda's words that we are meting the lurking legend who has some kind of connection to WB. Well we do know that Shiki had contact with WB and Roger. Yet I am not sure he is the lurking legend I mean his connection with WB din't seem that strong as to give a hint towards Shiki.

    Cons of this theory:
    Most likely than not, Kaido is the top dog , They might be collaborating but the whole thing about the lion being on top of the food chain is bs when infront of Kaido

    Shiki as being related to WB is questionable.

    There is no reason for shiki to hide his name

    Pros:
    Time line
    Lurking legend tho questionable
    Shiki is not dead
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Thanks for your review! Lots of important points you bring up.

      Keep in mind I did say there is a chance that Shiki could be the "King" calamity of Kaido, meaning he plays a significant role but is still under Kaido.

      Imo, Shiki fits the role of Lurking Legend way to well. "Lurking" implies hiding, and the only other legend that has been shown to be hiding somewhat is Imu, who I doubt has a connection to Whitebeard. Shiki, on the other hand, is a legend AND has a connection to Whitebeard.

      (Also, I think Oda meant someone that has a connection to Whitebeard rather than someone actually related to him)

      As for the name change, there is a chance that the people of Wano don't know of Shiki, but the underworld people do. He would have to change his name, just like Doflamingo used the name "Joker", to remain hidden.
  2. RandaAlzifahri
    RandaAlzifahri
    2/5,
    Have you seen One Piece Strong World? That movie explain where is Shiki for 20 years, what did he do, what his his destination. And just because Caesar has same voice actor with Shiki's doctor, doesnt meant they're the same doctor. Once again, have you seen this film? In this film we could see that Caesar and Shiki's doctor have different fighting style. And if Shiki ia truly recent shogun, from many names in the world, why he chose "Orochi"? Because it didnt represent Shiki at all
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Any of your arguments about what happened in Strong World are completely invalid, since that movie was clearly stated to be non-canon.

      As for the name, that is a good point. I recently added many things to this post, including: "Orochi, which means snake, could refer to him being 'a treacherous or deceitful person', which actually a definition of the word snake."

      To answer your question, I have not watched Strong World. Watching the movies isn't a bad thing, but it can bias one's opinions even though they are blatantly stated to be non-canon, and clearly this is where your disagreement comes from. Aside from that, I feel like you are disregarding some clues that have been shown.

      For example, you say that it is impossible for Caesar Clown to be Shiki's doctor, but Caesar has had a different disguise every arc since his introduction, used multiple fake names, and has the same voice actor. Assuming he has another fake identity is very reasonable in my opinion.
  3. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    4/5,
    Your theory was wrong, but that's ok! You still brought up some good points for future speculation. There WAS a previously known user of the Yami Yami no mi since it's in the book, as you said.
  4. Timmy
    Timmy
    5/5,
    Nice theory dude. I feel like this lines up with Blackbeard's personality a lot, cunning yet luck dependent.
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Exactly! I agree completely, it goes well with his character! I like this much more than the theories of him finding out in a book or just already knowing.

      Anyways, thanks for your review!
  5. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    3/5,
    Nice theory. There are 2 big reasons why I disagree with this, which is why I left off 2 stars.

    1: Oda will not be able to accurately list 100 more unique devil fruits, so there is no reason for him to add this to the plot. The closest thing we will get to this is Kaido's artificial zoan army, which we have been heavily prepared for. Also, Law has no reason to give the marines that much power.

    2: There are only 2 requirements for becoming a warlord: strength and loyalty. Law has already proven strength even before the timeskip with his 200 million berry bounty, not to mention the rocky port incident and other actions during the timeskip that raised him to 440 million berries. As for loyalty, most people just seem to give the government something to prove it. Blackbeard gave an extremely wanted criminal, and Law gave 100 hearts of pirates. I don't think there needs to be any more significance than that.
    1. Sk1p1o
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the review.
      1: There is no reason too explain what these DF do. The only funktion of this is too show how DF work in a human body. It is totaly clear, that Oda will not explain 100 DF more too us, but so is it with Kido´s army. We will not know about every single zoan/smile-zoan, but they exist.
      2:The second point is a little weak, because in the aftermath of marine fort all marine admirals wanted more fighting power for the marine, including the warlords. So it is not usefull too compare the rules too become a warlord pre and post marine fort. And lets remember, that the marine had reasons too hate Law (Sabaody). Law came too them and offert them too make him a warlord. All other warlords were called by the world goverment themself. Law had too do something special too be a exaption and my text could contain the reason.
  6. red admiral
    red admiral
    2/5,
    a good Theroy need help of Manga

    Shanks with any DF would be too fucking strong for any one to beat so No ... not Blood not time not space ...

    he don't have DF
  7. Gomu_Gomu_no_MEAT
    Gomu_Gomu_no_MEAT
    5/5,
    Absolutely love the theory. Definitely getting the wheels grinding. i've had a gut feeling that the overall consensus about the Great Kingdom and the void century was a little off. It's part of Oda's style, but it's still missing something. I think this theory covers all area's of Oda's style. Kudos for the good work.
  8. Sk1p1o
    Sk1p1o
    4/5,
    Its a good idea, but i disagree on the point of the random starting plan. https://orojackson.com/one-piece-theories-and-speculations/laws-real-donation-for-the-wg.2543/ I think, that more people like Law or the world goverment know this too, so it is realistik, that BB-stealingmethod was already known, when he started stealing. BB plan seems too be very good thoght out, so it is not realy realistik, that it started spontaniasly. but i agree on the rest and your arguments are good. If you want read my text, too understand, why i think, that more people know about. Keep up your good work :)
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Thanks for your review! I appreciate the input :)

      Well, here's how I see it. Oda might just give Blackbeard knowledge of the Dark Dark fruit and all of it's abilities, but that still wouldn't explain how he knows the reincarnation. It's clear that he found out somehow, since other members of his crew are seen collecting them as well.

      And like I said, I don't think his starting plan was to kill Thatch. After all, if Blackbeard came across the fruit first, I think he would have just left quietly.

      In my theory, I did also say that the world government probably knows how devil fruit reincarnation works AND gave some justifications for it, but there is no reason that Law would know. (unless there is a plot twist and he ended seeing Corazon's fruit reappear off screen, but I'm not really sure what the significance of that would be.)
  9. Donal D. Trump
    Donal D. Trump
    5/5,
    Very nice and original. Its really never discussed why he had to kill Thatch and there might be mystery here. Blackbeard was able to hurt Shanks so stealing a fruit doesn't seem like a huge deal The only counter argument and that would be deadly to this theory is that he had to kill him so Thatch couldn't alarm the crew and Blackbeard could sail away quickly. I think if they had a real discussion or a beef and Thatch ate the fruit the crew would have noticed but I still like how original this idea is.
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Thanks! I appreciate the review!

      Well, I don't think that would be deadly to my theory. Thatch was killed because he ate the devil fruit (for whatever reason), not to silence him. Regardless, in the panels showing Thatch's death, nobody was around except for Blackbeard.

      It should also be mentioned that Blackbeard wasn't weak before the devil fruit, but that he was actually very strong. Shanks attested to this by saying that when he got his scar from Blackbeard that he wasn't being careless. This leads me to believe that Blackbeard could have one-shot Thatch, making it a quick and painless fight.
  10. RandaAlzifahri
    RandaAlzifahri
    5/5,
    This is good. I like your idea. This is great. Keep working. Good job
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the review, I appreciate it!
  11. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    5/5,
    Speculation: the forming of a theory or conjecture without firm evidence. (For those that don't know)

    This is a good speculation, very reasonable. Although letting Toki stay alive might bring up a plot hole for her devil fruit once she dies, but Oda could probably work around it.
    1. Timmy
      Author's Response
      Thankyou for your kind review. I think having time travel means that Oda believes he can deal with all the complications that come with it so I'm gonna trust him.
  12. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    1/5,
    Jack cut off their arms and used a poison gas weapon on them. Inuarashi and Nekomamushi are not traitors. If a Kozuki member was a triator, he would have to be on the Island and someone would know about it. It's extremely is obvious that the traitor is Bariete, the little monkey that is the lookout on Zou.
  13. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    5/5,
    This theory is definitely "out there", but you do have good reasoning behind it. I like the idea, but in my opinion it does seem a bit simple for that to beat him. Maybe using Conqueror's Haki weakens his defense?
  14. Su Long Bepo
    Su Long Bepo
    4/5,
    Nice theory. I agree that his observation haki is very advanced, but I'm not sure if Oda would add another form of advanced observation haki just for Mihawk. I don't think this is impossible, but I feel like there is no need to add that because Mihawk doesn't really need a buff.
  15. D jango
    D jango
    5/5,
    A very good point and explained well

    After this, maybe somebody want to put this simple idea in to their theory :)
    1. Su Long Bepo
      Author's Response
      Thanks! I'm glad you liked it!
  16. Ace1994
    Ace1994
    2/5,
    Lol does he kiss him or uses his fingers to stop the air like a balloon? *gave 2 stars to be different
  17. Quindale22
    Quindale22
    4/5,
    This would be awesome. Seeing that Zoro usually end up in important places when he get lost. And having Kidd try to bribe or beg to get out would be even better
    1. DarkMage_Kaizoku
      Author's Response
      That’s true he usually ends up somewhere interesting on his wondering around.
  18. AL sama
    AL sama
    1/5,
    I'll just ask one question

    if Shanks has a DF then how can he swim??
  19. Donal D. Trump
    Donal D. Trump
    5/5,
    Makes perfect sense. It will be a funny scene to say the least when Zoro doesn't care about him and Kidd has to beg lol.
    1. DarkMage_Kaizoku
      Author's Response
      Lol yeah, Kidd might have to bribe Zoro by saying: “ I know where Kaidou left his sake”.
  20. Godyonko
    Godyonko
    1/5,
    I totally disagree with about Sanji being a spy, when would he had time to join the opposition. And if he was a spy we would of found out on wci
    1. Pawkitt
      Author's Response
      It would have been an agreement made when him and Zeff got picked up on that rock. A 2nd sanji focused arc doesnt seem likely, your right. Its possible they'd quickly reveal him being a spy to get Zoro to accept Sanji's betrayal of the crew, as weird as that sounds. We should know soonish.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice