Latest Reviews

  1. haider90
    haider90
    4/5,
    Jack already uses Nitoryu. But most likely Jack will be fought by the minks tribe leaders because of the past. Zorro will most likely fight a samurai so a calamity with a sword style is highly unlikely. The only way i see it if the shogun is a calamity of Kiado . If he is then i think he already meets the criteria as Zorro opponent as he is a samurai as well as a calamity.
    So i guess this is how it goes
    Zorro Team Vs Shogun (Calamity i think)
    Inuarashi and Nekomamushi Team vs Jack
    Sanji Team Vs Another Calamity
    Luffy, Law, Kid, Marco and others Vs Kiado

    Moria Crocodile and Weeble will also be present. Black Beard pirates too.

    P.S this arc is way too complicated.......
  2. Veiz
    Veiz
    4/5,
    I'm still sceptic Sanji will be king although it depends on Judge's condition. But the closest one at least Germa and Strawhat will be allied, I can see that. But, this is great theory anyway!
    1. Tartan Owl
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the review nakama. I am glad you think it is a great theory.

      Also, it is good to be sceptical. That just means you are thinking very carefully about it.
  3. Gray D. Thomas
    Gray D. Thomas
    1/5,
    Luffy losing his fruit means death... plan and simple. Unless you mean his abilities negated by BB fruit which it doesn't seem you did. His Haki training was important bc of the necessary strength needed to attain his dream.
  4. haider90
    haider90
    3/5,
    Well i dont think so because of the promise they made to each other.
    I also doubt oda will introduce another training session in the story at this point. If there is indeed a training arc i think Scooper Gaban will train Straw Hats or give some tips.
  5. PurplePandaSage22
    PurplePandaSage22
    4/5,
    Not as good as part one but very interesting as well, especially pointing out the use of height or level = superiority
    1. Saffron Kaizoku
      Author's Response
      Yeah I agree lol, glad you got something from this too
  6. PurplePandaSage22
    PurplePandaSage22
    5/5,
    Honestly, the fandom needs more theories regarding the mythical and celestial links within onepiece.I always felt there was a reason used Hindu-Buddhist civilisation architecture for Jaya and Skypea arcs.And this theory provided me with some details I missed.Very good theory so 5*/5 from me.
    1. Saffron Kaizoku
      Author's Response
      Glad you got something from this & thanks ^^
  7. Coquet
    Coquet
    5/5,
    Very interesting, well-constructed and convincing theory !!
    That, plus Zoro having a major update on his origins during the wano arc will really fit to the plot, Luffy being already the son of an amazing man. This way the monster trio hype will continue until EoS.
    1. Tartan Owl
      Author's Response
      You are such a kind reviewer nakama. I am delighted you think so highly of this theory.

      Since Luffy & Sanji are directly related to powerful individuals, it would stand to reason that Zoro is too.

      Monster Trio hype forever!!!
  8. PurplePandaSage22
    PurplePandaSage22
    5/5,
    Freakin hilarious and I hope Oda adresses the rest in future SBS's or data books
    1. Shu
      Author's Response
      I hope so. thanks for the reviews xD
  9. Skeleton Brook
    Skeleton Brook
    4/5,
    Hi ! great theory, we appreciate the effort. Even though I do not share all of your views, I think you still have interesting ideas about Germa's future. To me, the SW do not have to act like Yonkos (gathering resources, having a permanent force with them etc), but Sanji becoming the king of Germa is not complete non-sense to me. Plus I like the way you mention the inspiration for Sanji, without building up everything around it. More theorists should do their theories this way. Thx a lot !
    1. Tartan Owl
      Author's Response
      Thank you for your review nakama. It means a lot to me. I am glad you enjoyed this theory even if you did not agree with everything in it. I will always appreciate an open-minded & honest reviewer.

      You could be correct. The Straw Hats may not act like any Yonko before them. They are very unpredictable after all.
  10. CAMUNAI
    CAMUNAI
    5/5,
    Yes yes yes. At first I thought there were some similarities between different groups but I saw the update later. 3 different groups is nice number, similar to zoans. Maybe we have 3 logia groups? Robin said the goro goro was a "invencible type".

    I can see the awakening you thought of luffy happening. But maybe he is still connected to his clones.

    It would be nice if you did a theory about what type of awakening every type of paramecia has.
  11. Denref
    Denref
    5/5,
    whoahhh nice theory again by u jinz :D i didn't realise that nice observation(as always)

    and never knew that amaterasu, tsukuyomi and susanoo is God.. i thought u talking about naruto before i read all things xD
    1. jinz
      Author's Response
      Actually many techniques in Naruto was named from Japanese deities^^. Anyways thanks for the review, I'm glad you like it.
  12. Vandenreich
    Vandenreich
    5/5,
    Why yes. I've always said that there are at least 5 clans representing the elements. Very simple, very possible and to the point.

    Did you know that there was a real life Kozuki castle that was sieged during the samurai era? Did you know that there was a council of 5 elders?
    1. jinz
      Author's Response
      Hi Van, thanks for the review

      A real life Kozuki castle huh, i didn't know that. Maybe i'll try to look more into that, thanks for the info.^^
  13. Elizabeth Edelweiss
    Elizabeth Edelweiss
    5/5,
    Dang it, Dave-sama.. i cannot say anything else, cool and love it!
    1. Dave
      Author's Response
      thanx eli chan :D
  14. MulliganTV
    MulliganTV
    4/5,
    i love the part at the end about king of kings. Looking at the crew already we have soul king and sogeking. if zoro beats the shogun that's basically samurai king.
    1. Tartan Owl
      Author's Response
      Your are so right nakama! A Soul King, a Sniper King, a Germa King and a Shogun all under the Pirate King does sound pretty epic!
  15. Gray D. Thomas
    Gray D. Thomas
    2/5,
    Appreciate the time and energy you put into this; however it's just not really something that fits sanji or the story at all. Sanji cares more about finding the all blue and being a chef than ruling over anything. As for Luffy being "king of kings" , his dream is to be king of the pirates which to him means being the most free. It has nothing to do with ruling over people as explained when he discussed this wiTh silvers Rayleigh at the rio off bar.
    1. Tartan Owl
      Author's Response
      I am glad you can appreciate effort nakama.

      Yes Sanji does care about those things & that is precisely why he will become king. In order to achieve his dream & the dreams of his crew, his family, Sanji knows they need more resources & manpower to fight the Yonko, defy the World Government, fight the Marines & reach Raftel.

      Luffy is already a king but he doesn't realise that. Luffy is a King of Men. He charms nearly anyone and everyone to help him through just the right mixture of selfishness & selflessness.

      Finally, Luffy's rise to Pirate King will be different to Roger's because the journey is different. When Roger made his journey, there were no Yonko or well established pirates that had been in the New World for decades. He did not need the resources that Luffy because his journey was a race against his rivals to see who could get to the end of the Grand Line first.

      Luffy by comparison, is having to fight not rival forces but superior forces. Thus he needs to gather far more allies than Roger ever had, in order to achieve his dream.
  16. Portgas D. Xatch
    Portgas D. Xatch
    4/5,
    3.5* but I round up, don't let bad reviews get you down...

    For a first post this was good..

    Firstly I agree with some of what you speculate... I don't believe eating a DF user or their heart grants the consumer the fruit... I believe Carmel is still alive in BM in a soul form...

    I don't know about Carmel being able to make human looking soul object tho.. All things given conscientious have that comical look, Prometheus and Zeus aren't realistic clouds they are cartoony...

    Regaurdles what I believe, ways to improve...

    You build up allot in the beginning, but fizzle out at the end... Whats the motive behind fake children, if Carmel's a slaver, why did she create lambs house..

    More visuals to support the argument, and look Into Perona, she has a seoul-based ability and a soul form very similar to Brooks and big mom.

    Also explain that you believe big mom just acquired the soul soul fruit because it would have been nearby
    1. strawhatwbtpe
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the feedback :)
  17. Murders
    Murders
    5/5,
    i like this theory. nice one mate. finding another conclusion from the history in real life.
    1. jinz
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the review, I'm glad you liked it. :)
  18. Cyrenz98
    Cyrenz98
    5/5,
    Definitely Great Theory. I see why only Kozuki clan can use that technique. I wonder if McGuy comes from Wano cause he has electric sword or maybe he learned that from Zou ...

    Excellent points about Japanese myth and connecting it to Kozuki Clan and Wano. Keep it up mate^^
    1. jinz
      Author's Response
      Thanks for the review Cyrenz ^^

      About Mcguy, yeah maybe he learned it from Wano or it is also possible that he is a half Mink.
  19. Kaido Jr.
    Kaido Jr.
    1/5,
    if she would have died before getting eating the devil fruit wouldn't have went into big mom so they was all eaten and they all was real not souls from mother caramel
    1. strawhatwbtpe
      Author's Response
      I don't understand what you're saying. My post is about what happened to everyone. If she died while Big Mom was eating the cake, then they all disappeared while Big Mom wasn't paying attention to them. This post has nothing to do with how Big Mom got her devil fruit powers. We have no reason to believe that eating someone gives you their devil fruit powers, in fact it's more than likely that eating someone wouldn't give you their devil fruit power. It's very possible that when someone dies, the devil fruit power goes into the closest fruit available, which most likely would've been eaten by Linlin since all she ever does is stuff her face with food.
  20. haider90
    haider90
    5/5,
    Damn.....the research and effort that went into this is insane...bravo.
    I still think Uranus will be revealed in Elbaf arc. It is the reason Elbaf is the strongest nation in One piece(no wonder big mom wanted them as allies). Uranus will be used to destroy redline, if it is part of the story.
    Once again nicely crafted theory.
    1. CAMUNAI
      Author's Response
      I also believe that Uranus is going to be revealed in Elbaf, since I think there is a connection between the D clan, winged race and giants.

      In the norse mythology fairies lived below Ygdrasil, the great tree, so maybe we found a D family there who can explain us more about Uranus ( VOAT in my opinion). Also, since pluton and anti-pluton will already have enough destruction power I dont see the necessity of having another destructive ancient weapon. The word "weapon" has too negative connotations maybe. But you still might be right.

      Thanks for you support and for appreciating the theory even if your opinion is different