Latest Reviews

  1. Arthand
    Arthand
    5/5,
    nice i also thought swedish thing maybe Nami has some connection to elbaf.
  2. Arthand
    Arthand
    5/5,
    I think it wasn't the pirates that destroyed the island but marines(A possible kingdom that opposed WG) ,which made Bellemere lose faith in marines. Even in arlongs case she never believed in marines also it is ironic a corrupt marine was helping arlong. I think Nojiko knew who Nami is but didn't tell Bellemere(maybe Nojiko was maids daughter while Nami was the newborn Princess but for some reason WG wanted her who know Uranus maybe who knows), Nojiko was told to take Nami and run but would you trust someone who came to kill you so she lied. I think Bellemere somehow noticed Namis identity and didn't registered them to town.
  3. Timmy
    Timmy
    2/5,
    I think the reason a lot of people see The Supernovas and other people as potential allies is because of Luffy's ability to win people over.
    1. Portgas D. Xatch
      Author's Response
      I agree, Mihawk stated this was his true power. The point of the speculation isn't necessary to be right. But to think outside the box. Thx for the review
  4. CAMUNAI
    CAMUNAI
    4/5,
    I would add " the support of some kings". And well, Luffys health may get worse in the future. I also think that rogers disease may be something like the sickness of love or so. Anyways very interesting.
  5. Zero Zero No Mi
    Zero Zero No Mi
    5/5,
    I am shocked !!! Your theory is magnificient ! You greatly connected all these chess variants and this arc! I'm hyped about the Sanji vs Katakuri chess fight and the target being Streusen. A good reasoning quite logical and exciting !! Good point about Castling !

    About Chester Cat saving everyone, I like the idea of Neko/Marco but I saw some theories of Absa being this cat due to his power. He could be there already with Moria hidden. ..

    Wish to see more of you! It's the best theory I read here since a long long time!
    1. CAMUNAI
      Author's Response
      I see!! That would make total sense! Absalom and Moria are connected to Lola too. I thought that maybe the fairy is Monet and the fairy chess piece could be Vergo, a man with a lot of smile powered parts attached.
  6. Krillin25
    Krillin25
    2/5,
    I don't think it happens in Wano, if they do fight. It might even come down to Luffy versus Weevil. I think that the other reasons are ok, but I don't think Marco really cares about the heir part. You're really wrong on the Weevil caring about wealth thing as well. Good try.
  7. CAMUNAI
    CAMUNAI
    3/5,
    Will the tree hommy join the crew? Luffy wanted a tree from thriller bark as nakama
    1. mbn789
      Author's Response
      Lol, nah I don't think that would ever happen.
  8. CAMUNAI
    CAMUNAI
    2/5,
    I prefer this than "all supernovas vs kaido". But just because the numbers match doesnt mean this has to happen. You are suggesting that the strawhats could fight against nine supernovas. But what would their crews do? Wouldnt they want to fight against them too?
    Personally, I think more plausible other dupernova alliances to happen. Three supernova crew trios
    1. Portgas D. Xatch
      Author's Response
      Your probably right, this is just an out of the normal speculation, the teaming up against kaido is what everyone thinks, and isn't original.

      Plus this drawn from the widely believed assumption that the SH's will have individual fights with the BB pirates. Yet no one questions what the other 100sone odd people in BB crew will do why 9-10 captains of commanders fight...

      I appreciate any and all reviews
  9. Jeffrey zorofan
    Jeffrey zorofan
    2/5,
    I totally agree with Diabolique's opinion... Thing I wanna add is that it's not sharing Ace death but the recruits and Luffy are able to empathize with each other coz... Brook didnt meet Ace... The female recruits joined in an imposing way... Nami was obliged to join by luffy coz they needed a navigator... Robin imposed herself coz she had nowhere to go... I see Vivi as part of Luffy's fleet...

    Vivi also lacks paralleling with Nami and Robin, Like:
    Nami n Robin gave a directional item, Grandline map n eternal pose respectively.
    They are part of one of the strongest pirate crews in the current sea.
    Nami was in Arlong's crew in East Blue, which is considered the weakest sea and fishmen were said to be 10x better than humans. You can assume that the Arlong pirate crew was one of the strongest in East Blue.
    Robin was in Crocodile's crew, a shichibukai. They were presented as overpowered and the strongest of Grandline. The emphasis wasnt yet put on yonkos, not much was known about them.

    Nami joins from one of the strongest crews in East Blue.
    Robin from Paradise.
    Right now yonkos are considered the strongest of the new world, my bet would be on Pudding... I'm not saying she's definitely joining but she has the highest chances.

    Since she also gave a directional item, a path map and shes in the crew of one of the yonkos who rule these seas. There are even more paralleling I didnt mention.

    Like you said female stories are delayed... Not much about 3 eyed tribe is known yet. Her tribe could also have been obliterated coz her people can decipher the ancient language, thanks to VOAT... I think since she's a mutt her 3rd eye ability will b different or there will be a special poneglyph uncodable by Robin which would give her a spot in the crew...

    The way I see it the Bm pirates will be weakened(maybe thnx to tamate box), n Luffy&co will be able to flee. There will be a rematch after the defeat of Kaido, maybe on Elbaf since giants hold a grudge against BM and I cant see the her defeat without giants in the picture.

    I think someone with a pet will join but it may not be Vivi and Carue. It would be someone with the tamer/summoner theme. If Vivi joins her butler would have too since he looks after her. That's why they would fit better as fleet.
    1. AnonymousStrawHat
      Author's Response
      Brook was shown sharing Luffys pain as was the whole crew. Puffy also asked him as well to put his dreams on hold for 2 years and he called it a selfish act himself. They have stronger bonds because of it.

      What fleet? In all likelihood Vivi will become a fugitive. She is relevant in the story again so she has time to give a directional item and a bunch of other stuff. She is royalty dating back from the void century so she is part of a powerful group.

      I think Pudding could join too because she passed the Main Criteria and I only eliminated her because Tashigi and Vivi had more screen time and can relate with Ace. Her chances are still high.
  10. AlloftheOP
    AlloftheOP
    5/5,
    mate this is excellent, well done, so in depth and it's your first theory holy **** any chance you'd let me make a video about this for youtube, will credit you completely and link this thread
    also following because i want to see what you think up next
    1. CAMUNAI
      Author's Response
      Much apreciated! Well, i am thinking myself of doing a video for youtube but I it may be in spanish so it ok if you want to do it. PM me if you have any question
  11. Jaguar D. Saul
    Jaguar D. Saul
    5/5,
    Really amazing the way you connected all the chess play styles with one piece.i really like the idea Sanji Vs Katakuri intelligent fight.What an awasome theory.
  12. Timmy
    Timmy
    2/5,
    The power of the devil fruit can't be in the heart because when Law swaps people heart's the power doesn't go with them.
    1. cardboardspectator
      Author's Response
      We dont know exactly how devil fruits work so we cant make that assumption. It could just be that the devil is housed in the heart but person's body still retains the power of the fruit.
  13. AnonymousStrawHat
    AnonymousStrawHat
    4/5,
    I like this because it keeps everything uniform and its accurate. Caribu is different, he makes me think of Senor Pink and Blamenco mixed. His powers are weird and your right about it not being interesting if he can make a big swamp.

    Keep D.D.F series up.
    1. Portgas D. Xatch
      Author's Response
      Tyvm for the review and suggestions, I really appreciate it!
  14. cardboardspectator
    cardboardspectator
    5/5,
    Like the poster said before me, I dont think the predictions will happen however your connections to chess was very interesting and well thought out so you definitely deserve 5 stars. Also dont think that Sanji will do anything too strategic cause frankly, he doesn't really show that much aptitude in strategy and Jimbe and Capone are far better suited for that task.

    Oda may use some chess tactics here and there but I dont think he will go as far with the idea as you seem to imply.
  15. Portgas D. Xatch
    Portgas D. Xatch
    4/5,
    Is about the best I can give now a days on this topic. Multiple Hearts, unborn/ Siamese twins, Cerberus fruit, etc... This is such a saturated topic, almost nothing you said was a new speculation. 4* because it's a well put together post
  16. Diabolique
    Diabolique
    2/5,
    Everybody crew member has a “place” to return. Brook does not share Ace’s death, they did not meet each other. The main crew member pattern is: 1.Luffy needs help to do something that he can't do himself. 2. The member has a dream and can achieve it with Luffy. Lik you said, Cobra is dying and Vivi is his only daughter. She has no dream, her dream is to protect Alabasta, the reason sh rejected the offer. I do believe in the MFMM and 13 members. You also forgot the "akuma no mi numbers" pattern, fortifies the 13 members argument. I do believe a woman will join to fill this hole in the crew... I was expecting a future Kunoichi from Wano. But now, since Luffy did not go to Wano by going to WCI.. I don't think he has "time" to meet a Kunoichi or anyone from Wano deeply to invite him. My bets are in Carrot. Kinemon and Momonosuke. You had unhappy arguments about them both.
    1. AnonymousStrawHat
      Author's Response
      Brook did share the pain with Luffy and I didn't use the number patter technique because I made my point without it. And I probably don't understand it well enough but it's seems suggestive.

      I think Carrot can be a Straw Hat because she passed the Main Criteria. Kinemon and Momo didn't so I don't see them as possible crew members. You do have an argument about Vivi but she may not even be able to return to Alabasta because we know what her father is going to say and because Wapol will spite her. This will be her big tragedy, not Alabasta Arc. Everybody's dream is can be tied to their tragedy, so she will get a new dream.

      I like the points you made. Good review.
  17. Tokiro Oumaga
    Tokiro Oumaga
    4/5,
    I definitely agree that Vivi seems like a strong candidate, and I have been thinking myself lately that the remaining recruits will likely be characters introduced in the past. I don't agree with the point about having nowhere to return to, though, as except for Brook and Robin who lost everything, all of the Straw Hats do have at least one but typically multiple people who would love and accept them if they returned. I do like the point about Vivi+Carue matching Doc Q+Stronger, and I would rather like to see that fight.
  18. Ziki
    Ziki
    5/5,
    I am not sure about those predictions, especially the Sanji one's as while sure he often comes up with strategies, most of the time he is the one executing them but he is rarely the one who orders other around.

    But prediction aside, all those finds about what already happened are great and they let me appreciate the story a bit more than before so good job. Hopeful some of those ideas will come true.
  19. uTopia D. LighT
    uTopia D. LighT
    5/5,
    Nice ! I am feeling asleep but i'll make it short lol.
    Nice points and demonstrating, you made things clear even for the dummies like me although it is very detailed.
    Enjoyed Reading and expecting next ones :D well done Man
  20. NikyuTai
    NikyuTai
    4/5,
    I like just how deep you went for the ties to come together about Kuma. Some of them I feel are a bit far fetched but at the same time, there isn't much confirmed information about Kuma at all. So with so little information and finding what you did, I'd say it's a job well done. Hopefully we get more info about Kuma once we get to Wano. I do agree with you from the points you made that Kuma is most likely from Wano. Hype for Wano arc!

    Enjoyed this theory a lot, thanks for posting it!