Theory Big Mom's Strongest - The 'Sweet Commanders' POWERS AND IDENTITIES

In depth theory talking about who i believe to be the 3 sweet commanders and their powers.

  1. Dragomir
    Dragomir
    5/5,
    This theory is nothing less of excellent you've outdone yourself bro. I can see Mont d'oh being the minister ofcheese.!
  2. Blue gear
    Blue gear
    5/5,
    some very well established connections and thoughts! did not notice half of what you presented, so good to read! thanks!
  3. NovaBounty
    NovaBounty
    3/5,
    You've done an excellent theory here. Sadly the commander are Smoothie and Kataruki ( witch are both sugar names) So the minister of Candy and the minister of Nuts does not fit in the criterion of Smoothie or Kataruki.
  4. MUUGEN
    MUUGEN
    5/5,
    Wow finally had a chance to read this one, glad that I did. Really great job connecting all those dots and tying everything together. My favorite part was about Bobbins since he has been the character I have been wanting to learn about the most.

    Tag me in any future theories please.
  5. Leyda
    Leyda
    5/5,
    Ok so, this theory was so effing awesome!! I can't believe how you guys actually pull this off but i'm glad you do. xD Oh and that guy is the Whipped Cream Minister. You were right about Mont D'or to be related to Cheese though. Again, splendid theory. Good job m8. :3
  6. Aloe Vera
    Aloe Vera
    4/5,
    That's truly a great theory.

    The only thing I dislike is Bobbin being a Minister, but that's very subjective, and he possibly could be one anyway.

    I follow you on YouTube and I really appreciate your videos, so I'll thank you in this review !..
  7. Aussie Aussie No Mi
    Aussie Aussie No Mi
    5/5,
    Great theory!!

    Totally agree with Perospero being one of the commanders. Ever since he got the Oda Box I was certain Bug moms firstborn would be one of the commanders
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      It's very intuitive to think Perospero may be one,I just wish we could be more certain with facts xD alas, they are lacking! Still, as I said it's very easy to believe it, and doing so adds a lot of support to my theory ^^
  8. uhraman
    uhraman
    5/5,
    Excellent work. You gave a very thoughful and full of evidences for your theory.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thank you so much :)
  9. Railgun99
    Railgun99
    5/5,
    This was another great theory! I can't believe I didn't read it before as I read most of your theories! I really like how you connected the island names and the minister titles with the Sweet Commanders. And I also like how the potential future DFs of the future Commanders as well as Cracker's, at first glance, seems pretty ridiculous but turns out to be OP (that's what happened for Cracker anyway so I'm sure the same will be for the other Sweet Commanders). I definitely think that Perospero will be someone very important. And judging by that map Pudding gave, if you look at it, after Biscuit Island, we get Nut and lastly Candy (if I'm not mistaken), maybe that is the order of the Commanders they'll meet to get to Big Mom. Just a thought ^^
    Minister of Chocolate indeed is very intriguing and the same is with Bobbins, classic Oda foreshadowing if Bobbins turns out to be some kind of trump card for Big Mom at the end with the Dressrosa incident with toys! It was a great read!
    If you don't mind, please tag me in your future theories!
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      The order actually would be (if the map is foreshadowing) Candy, Nut, Biscuit. So Pero would be the strongest and Cracker the weakest ^^ I will tag you for sure ^^
  10. Ethan
    Ethan
    5/5,
    I couldn't have thought of such a theory myself. I especially liked how you concluded who the two remaining sweet commanders are based on facts. Well done mate, literally.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      I spend too much time thinking about One piece xD but I appreciate you taking your time to send such a kind message!
  11. Hyakuachi
    Hyakuachi
    5/5,
    Great theory but I think there are 3 commanders and Bobbins is not one of them but he is the strongest subordinate of BM
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Yes, a lot of people think Bobbin is a sweet commander, when I initially posted this theory to YT that was the most common comment. However, I think I agree with you... I think Bobbin is just a very strong subordinate not a "family" member. But if you do think Bobbin is a family member, the last section of the theory could be very interesting!
  12. East
    East
    5/5,
    wow all the details we had so far have been sewn perfectly in this theory. I specially like how the map was referenced to point out the possibility that the islands in there are absed on Big Mom's strongest subordinates. Good job dude
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thank you very much ^^ I would like to say that of all the parts of this theory, the map was the one thing I didnt notice by myself xD That was mentioned to me in a comment on YT before I made the theory, and used it as additional(and VERY persuasive) evidence ^^
  13. Rudiger
    Rudiger
    5/5,
    Good theory... I cant think other DF that suit with Big Mom theme (food) .
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Yeah, her food theme is very strong xD
  14. ordinarystory
    ordinarystory
    5/5,
    The only problem with this theory is that the mentioned devil fruit powers are below average. I think biscuit biscuit fruit is a weak df but cracker is very strong because of his haki. Even though nut is hard and probably jam jam fruit is a logia, there are much stronger dfs out there. It is hard to believe that the top yonkou commanders are using below average dfs which waste their true potential. If they have top level dfs, then big mums pirates would be much stronger.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      A devil fruits strength is completely up to Oda IMO he can make them as strong as he wants based on his purpose for the charcater in the story and his own imagination ^^ dont sleep on these seemingly very weak devil fruits!
  15. nicolaw_h
    nicolaw_h
    5/5,
    WOW!! really nice theory mate :)

    i am speechless haha...its just seems like oda's thinking.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thanks xD I hope so, I feel very confident in this theory but Oda likes to troll theory makers all the time lmao
  16. Zoronoa Roro
    Zoronoa Roro
    5/5,
    Great work, makes complete sense pretty much everything you have said.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thank you so much :)
  17. Yaksha
    Yaksha
    5/5,
    Damn good theory with hella evidence. Like how you had panels good reasoning nd facts to back up your claims. Also liked the real life cheese reference.
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thanks!! Just as a side note though, these cheese reference was mentioned to me by Raizo the theorist of youtube, you should check him out! I just felt it added to the ideas I was trying to get across ^^
  18. Shanks D Rodger
    Shanks D Rodger
    5/5,
    I agree with Bobbin being the minister of Nuts everything makes sense. Good Job Mate!
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Thank you so much :)
  19. TheMeans
    TheMeans
    5/5,
    Great Theory. I agree with this 100% and won't be suprised if it turns out to be true
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      Me too... but i'm scared of thinking this way because Oda will certainly troll me xD
  20. Buchaj
    Buchaj
    5/5,
    Amazing theory that made me think a lot I belive that the 4 commanders each have their own island and their powers resemble the name of the islands :D
    1. Joy_Boy
      Author's Response
      I'm glad I persuaded you!!! :)